Hearts2Hearts Ian’s Rendition of Aespa Karina’s Solo Track Ignites Intense Reactions
Hearts2Hearts’ Ian is facing backlash after her solo stage sparked heated reactions.
The controversy began when SM Entertainment announced Ian would perform the song “UP” by aespa’s Karina—a track Karina never performed on a major stage herself.
Ian’s special stage went live recently. Many fans praised her skills despite her rookie status, saying she did well.
However, some fans slammed the performance.
she’s a mess
— Kiara (@aenovaaa) December 31, 2025
Performing a song that the original artist never had the opportunity to perform at major shows is absurd.
— sowaerbi (@nemopilema_) December 31, 2025
should’ve just let karina perform her damn song sigh..
https://t.co/EEu7cQ7qyB— aji (@kkiusgf) December 31, 2025
Meanwhile, support poured in on Korean forum theqoo. Users praised Ian’s visuals and stage presence.
“She’s killing it—this concept suits her so well, and she’s beautiful.”
“Her arms are so long, it looks really graceful.”
“Absolutely stunning.”
“She performs so well on stage.”
“Ah, she’s just too good.”
“Her talent is the kind that’s meant for being an entertainer.”
Here are clips from Ian’s performance:
The debate is ongoing as fans weigh in on whether Ian should have performed the track instead of Karina herself.